WHINFELL HOUSE

During the second half of the 19th century many steel magnates built houses in the Whirlow area away from the pollution in the city. One such magnate was Samuel Doncaster who bought land at Whinfell, a site which offered beautiful views over Ecclesall woods to Dore and to the hills at Holmesfield. The construction of the house began in 1898 and the family moved in two years later. It was a grand and imposing property, approached by a long carriage drive and surrounded by lawns and flower beds. He also bought the adjoining quarry which he developed as a secluded and exotic garden, planting it with many specimens from around the world including Giant Redwood trees, acers and bamboo.

When Samuel Doncaster died in 1934 Whinfell House was bought by Frederick Neill, son of 1923 Master Cutler James Neill. Frederick lived at Whinfell for 30 years and became Master Cutler himself in 1937. In 1968 the family company, James Neill Holdings, gave the Quarry Garden to the City Council to be used as a public garden in memory of Sir Frederick. The garden, which is maintained by Sheffield City Council and ‘friends of Whinfell Quarry Garden’ has heritage status.

Lady Winifred Neill, widow of Sir Frederick, stayed at Whinfell House until 1969. James Neill Holdings now owned the house and decided to convert it into an office base and hospitality suite but during the conversion work, in 1971, the house was badly damaged by fire. The company made the decision to sell the estate.